The short answer
Charcoal gives the best balance of flavour and high heat for most grilling. Gas wins on convenience and control. Wood gives the most smoke flavour and the hottest fires, but demands the most skill. For a deeper look at why charcoal cooking is so popular, see the benefits of charcoal cooking.
| Charcoal | Gas (LPG) | Wood | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flavour | Smoky, charred | Clean, neutral | Strongest smoke flavour |
| Top heat | Very high: 300°C+ above the coals, 400°C+ in a tandoor | Usually 260–320°C | Very high, 400°C+ in ovens |
| Time to start | 20–30 min | 5–10 min | 30–60 min to get good coals |
| Control | Good with practice (vents, zones) | Excellent (a knob) | Hardest |
| Upfront cost | Low (grills start cheap) | Higher | Low to very high (pizza ovens) |
| Cleanup | Ash to empty | Minimal | Most ash |
| Smoke | Low once lit | Very low | Highest |
Flavour: why charcoal tastes different
Most of the smoky flavour on grilled food actually comes from fat and juices dripping onto the hot coals and vaporising, then rising back onto the food. Charcoal's intense radiant heat also browns food quickly, creating deeply flavourful crusts through the Maillard reaction. Gas grills can get some of this effect, but the heat is gentler and there is no glowing bed to vaporise drippings in the same way.
Wood goes further still: burning wood releases aromatic smoke compounds, which is why wood-fired pizza and smoked meats taste so distinctive. Too much wood smoke, though, makes food bitter.
Heat: charcoal and wood win
A full bed of charcoal radiates far more heat than most home gas grills, which is why charcoal gives a better sear on steaks, tikka and kebabs. In a clay tandoor, charcoal reaches temperatures no domestic gas appliance can. Wood-fired ovens reach 400 to 480°C, perfect for Neapolitan pizza in 90 seconds, which is why we sell pizza oven wood.
Convenience: gas wins
Gas starts at the turn of a knob and the temperature changes instantly. For quick weeknight grilling, that is hard to beat. Charcoal takes 20 to 30 minutes to be ready, but that time is not wasted: it is when you prep the food and pour the drinks.
Cost
Charcoal grills are much cheaper to buy than gas grills. Per cook, a family barbecue uses around 2 to 5 kg of charcoal. Gas costs less per hour of cooking, but you have to buy a gas grill and refill or replace cylinders. For occasional grilling, charcoal usually works out cheaper overall.
Health and environment
- Any very high-heat cooking of meat, on charcoal, gas or wood, can form compounds such as HCAs and PAHs, especially on charred parts. Marinating, trimming fat to cut flare-ups, flipping regularly, avoiding heavy charring, and grilling more vegetables all reduce them.
- Charcoal and wood must only be burnt outdoors because of carbon monoxide. See our safety guide.
- Sustainability: charcoal from waste wood, offcuts or coconut shells is far better than charcoal from cleared forests. Read how charcoal is made.
How to choose
- Choose charcoal if flavour and high heat matter most, and you enjoy the process.
- Choose gas if you grill often on weeknights and want speed and simplicity.
- Choose wood for pizza ovens, traditional cooking like dum biryani, and smoking.
- Or combine them: many cooks add a handful of wood chips to charcoal for extra smoke.
Frequently asked questions
Does charcoal really taste better than gas?
Most people taste a difference. Charcoal runs hotter, which gives a better crust, and drippings vaporise on the coals to add smoky flavour. Gas gives a cleaner, more neutral taste.
Is charcoal or gas healthier?
The fuel matters less than how you cook. High-heat charring on any fuel forms potentially harmful compounds. Marinate, avoid burning, trim fat and include vegetables to reduce them.
Can I use wood in a charcoal grill?
Yes. Add a few chunks or a handful of soaked wood chips to lit charcoal for extra smoke flavour. Burning only wood in a small grill is harder to control.