At a glance
| Hardwood lump | Briquettes | Coconut shell | Binchotan | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Made from | Whole pieces of hardwood | Charcoal dust pressed with a binder | Coconut shells, as lumps or pressed into briquettes | Hardwood (traditionally ubame oak) fired at very high heat |
| Lights | Fast, 10–15 min | Slower, 20–25 min | Medium to slow | Very slow, 30+ min |
| Heat | Very hot, varies by piece | Medium, very even | Hot and even | Very hot and steady |
| Burn time | Good | Long | Long | Very long, 3–5 hrs |
| Smoke | Low once lit | Low to medium depending on binder | Very low | Almost none |
| Ash | Low | High | Low | Very low |
| Price | Moderate | Low to moderate | Moderate | Very high |
| Best for | Searing, tikka, kebabs, tandoor | Long BBQs, low and slow | Long, clean cooks; hookah | Yakitori, premium grilling |
Hardwood lump charcoal
Lump charcoal is wood that has been slowly carbonised in a kiln with little oxygen. It keeps the shape of the original wood, so the pieces are irregular. It is the traditional fuel of Indian tandoors, kebab stalls and sigris.
Pros: lights quickly, burns very hot, responds fast to vents, very little ash, and contains nothing but carbonised wood.
Cons: irregular pieces burn at different rates, and quality varies a lot between suppliers. Lump made from mixed scrap wood sparks and burns unevenly.
The quality depends on the wood and on how slowly it was made. Dense hardwood carbonised over several days gives dense pieces that ring when tapped together and burn for hours. That is how we make our hardwood charcoal.
Briquettes
Briquettes are made by grinding charcoal into dust and pressing it into uniform pillow or hexagon shapes with a binder, usually starch. Some cheap briquettes also contain fillers such as clay, and self-lighting types are soaked in accelerant.
Pros: very consistent heat and long, steady burn, which makes them ideal for slow cooking such as ribs. Usually cheaper per hour of burning.
Cons: slower to light, lower peak heat, more ash, and some smell during lighting depending on the binder. Avoid self-lighting briquettes for food.
Coconut shell charcoal
Coconut shells are very dense and carbonise into hard, clean charcoal. You can buy it as small lumps or pressed into briquettes. India, Sri Lanka, Indonesia and the Philippines are major producers, using shells left over from the coconut industry.
Pros: hot, long-burning, very low smoke and ash, and made from a waste product rather than trees, which makes it the most sustainable option. Coconut briquettes are the standard for hookah because they produce no taste or smell.
Cons: takes longer to light than hardwood lump; small lumps can fall through wide grates.
Binchotan (white charcoal)
Binchotan is a Japanese charcoal made from hard oak. Near the end of firing, the kiln is opened, the glowing charcoal is pulled out and smothered in a mix of sand, earth and ash. The result is extremely hard, metallic-sounding charcoal with a whitish surface, which is why it is called white charcoal.
Pros: burns for hours at steady high heat with almost no smoke or smell. Prized for yakitori and premium Japanese grills. It can be put out and reused several times.
Cons: very expensive, hard to light (it needs a gas burner or a long time in a chimney), and can crack and spark if lit too quickly while damp.
Which should you buy?
| If you are cooking… | Choose |
|---|---|
| Tikka, kebabs, steak, anything that needs a fast, hot sear | Hardwood lump |
| A restaurant or home tandoor | Dense tandoor charcoal |
| A long party or low-and-slow cooking | Coconut briquettes |
| Something where low smoke matters (terraces, hookah) | Coconut shell charcoal |
| Yakitori or a special occasion | Binchotan |
Many experienced cooks mix types: lump charcoal for a fast, hot start, with briquettes underneath for steady heat over a long cook.
Frequently asked questions
Which charcoal burns the longest?
Binchotan burns longest, followed by coconut shell charcoal and briquettes. Hardwood lump burns hotter but for a shorter time.
Is lump charcoal better than briquettes?
Neither is better for everything. Lump lights faster, burns hotter and leaves less ash, which suits searing. Briquettes burn longer and more evenly, which suits slow cooking.
Is coconut charcoal good for BBQ?
Yes. Coconut shell charcoal burns hot and long with very little smoke or ash. It takes a little longer to light than hardwood lump.
What charcoal is used in tandoors?
Dense hardwood lump charcoal, because it holds high heat for hours and responds quickly when topped up.